The Supreme Court today ruled that the record Governor Gavin Newsom submitted with his request for the court’s permission to commute the life without parole sentence of Howard Ford will remain partially inaccessible to the public. A redacted version of the record is open for inspection.

The court’s recommendation is a constitutional prerequisite to a governor granting clemency to anyone, like Ford, who has been “twice convicted of a felony.”

The court made a similar sealing ruling last September regarding six other clemency records. Even a partial opening of a clemency record is unlikely unless a third party files a motion to unseal.

This is the second time a governor has asked the court to sign off on a sentence commutation for Ford. The first recommendation request was one of 10 made by then-Governor Jerry Brown that the court turned down. (See here and here.) The court has said it reviews those requests under a deferential standard. (See here and here.)


Governor must again re-do requests to keep clemency records secret

Supreme Court finalizes revised policy on clemency record confidentiality

“Free speech groups ask high court to open clemency records”

“Sanctions sought against governor over redacted clemency records”

More clemency records partially unsealed

Why is secrecy the default on gubernatorial clemency recommendation requests?

Supreme Court denies Governor’s bid to seal entire clemency files, but gives him a do-over to seek partial secrecy

Motions fail to pry loose Supreme Court’s clemency denial reasons

More clemency files might be opened, at least partially

“State high court orders unsealing of governor’s pardon documents”